The most expensive Innistrad card is the Crimson Vow. The art on this was made by Daarken, a “Magic: the Gathering” artist who has won a Grand Prix and been inducted into multiple Hall of Fame tournaments. This gives it a unique flavor that transcends any other cards in the set
The “mtg crimson vow cards” is a card from the Magic: The Gathering trading card game. It’s an expensive rare and mythic rare with a price tag of $1,000 or more.
The current set for Magic: The Gathering, Innistrad Crimson Vow, is the first standard set to be published over the Christmas season. As a result, market appraisal is utterly unpredictable.
Crimson Vow is currently estimated to have a lower expected value than Innistrad Midnight Hunt. The absence of highly significant cards for standard and contemporary formats, the lack of one truly strong new planeswalker, and the Crimson Vow product’s overall niche character are all contributing factors.
With that stated, take a look at this list of Innistrad Crimson Vow’s most expensive MtG cards and draw your own judgments.
Note that the prices stated relate to the publication date of this article, which is November 10, 2021.
Caretaker in Avabruck
- Regular pricing for art: $14.50
- $24.62 for the extended art pricing
Werewolf decks have been on the upswing in various formats since the release of Innistrad Midnight Hunt a few months ago. Support cards for wolf and werewolf tribal decks were included in the new Innistrad Crimson Vow set.
Avabruck Caretaker is a fantastic card, but it’s a little too pricey for competitive formats other than commander. That’s where it fits nicely in with Tovolar and Dire Overlord decks, and that’s why it’s being pushed up in price.
Obviously, the price will drop after the first surge, so anticipate it to be about $3-5 per piece.
The Corrosive Toxrill
- Regular price of art: $14.57
- The cost of a showcase piece of art is $21.80.
Toxrill is another another example of commander gimmickry. It’s a really strong card, but it’s a little sluggish and pricey. Even so, the EDH community loves it and will endeavor to include it into the structure.
The price will be set solely on the basis of its performance. Many believe it will be eliminated immediately after it arrives on the battlefield, causing many players to remove it from their decks and tanking the price.
This card’s market future will most likely be similar to that of Avabruck Caretaker.
Illuminator of Cemeteries
- Regular pricing for art: $15.31
- $22.50 for the extended art.
In the Crimson Vow set, spirits receive a lot of love, and Cemetery Illuminator is one of the more intriguing new spirit mythics.
Apart from being an obvious pick for commander, current players see it as a possible addition to the Azorius Spirits deck in the format.
Cemetery Illuminator’s pre-release pricing was $25, however was ultimately decreased to $15. This indicates that market trust in the card’s worth has been eroding.
It’s difficult to predict where the price will go, but it seems to be another example of a $5 card.
Desecrator of Cemeteries
- Regular pricing for art: $15.79
Cemetery Desecrator is a new utility card for the Dimir Zombies archetype in Commander.
Other formats seem to be ignoring this relatively pricey beast, which limits its commercial use. Cemetery Desecrator, like a few other commander-friendly cards mentioned above, seems to be on the way down in price.
It could make its way into casual play and become a true star there, but as the price reduces, it won’t be able to reclaim its original $15 pricing. So, at best, anticipate it to continue in the $3-5 range.
Gatekeeper at a cemetery
- $19.00 for a regular piece of art
- The cost of a showcase piece of art is $14.83.
Another Crimson Vow cemetery card, although this one is much more fascinating than Cemetery Desecrator or even Cemetery Illuminator.
It’s already seen use in Mono-Red pioneer decks, Mardu Vampire decks in modern, Boros and Rakdos aggressive decks in standard, and a slew of other commander archetypes.
This expands the market for this card significantly. Its presale price was $30, which was greater than normal, but it has already dropped to roughly $20. It might go further lower, but the lowest price is likely to be around $7-10, which is something to keep in mind.
Geist Hunter, Kaya
- $19.53 for a regular piece of art
- $32.51 for borderless art
Geist Hunter, Kaya is the Crimson Vow set’s most lackluster new planeswalker.
It has no inherent power and must be backed by tokens in order to do anything worthwhile. Except for commander, every other format has ignored Kaya, and her price has been slowly declining since her reveal.
Some traders are selling it for less than $10, implying that the lowest price will be around $2-3.
Kaya, Geist Hunter
- $19.53 for a regular piece of art
- $32.51 for borderless art
Kaya, Geist Hunter is the Crimson Vow set’s most lackluster new planeswalker.
It has no inherent power and must be backed by tokens in order to do anything worthwhile. Except for commander, every other format has ignored Kaya, and her price has been slowly declining since her reveal.
Some traders are selling it for less than $10, implying that the lowest price will be around $2-3.
Chandra, Killer-In-Training
- $22.60 for a regular piece of art
- Price of borderless art: $35.40
Many players had great expectations for Chandra, the new planeswalker. While it’s fantastic in Mono-Red decks, it’ll be overlooked in any other archetype.
This, of course, makes her an extremely risky investment, and everyone is forecasting a fall from grace to the $5-7 level right now.
Mono-Red decks don’t fare well in standard these days, thus commander players will be the ones to play them. However, this is insufficient to ensure a strong market performance.
Sorin the Mirthless is a fictional character.
- $21.43 for a regular piece of art
- $32.93 for borderless art
- The cost of a showcase piece of art is $50.28.
Sorin is a good planeswalker, but not outstanding. It has certain valuable qualities that will be mostly overlooked in all forms except commander, which is bad news for investors.
The plus one ability is the most important here, and it reminds me of Dark Confidant. But why would players select Sorin the Mirthless over Dark Confidant, which costs much less mana?
So the only choice is to play in the standard format, where Dark Confidant is prohibited, but Sorin shouldn’t charge more than $7-10 per card.
Necroduality
- $21.70 for a regular piece of art
- Price of extended art: $35.55
This is is another card that will only be used in the Dimir Zombies archetype in commander and maybe standard.
It has a terrific impact, but since it is confined to the zombie tribe, it is unlikely to become an investment darling very soon. Expect it to drop to $8-12 a piece for all it’s worth.
It may go over that if it finds a home in an unexpected standard brew, but not by much. It’s just too specialized to make an impact in any format.
Colossus Cultivator
- Regular price of art: $29.45
- $34.56 for the extended art price
Cultivator Colossus, a gigantic trampler with immense potential in commander mode, is the most expensive card in Innistrad Crimson Vow. However, it does not seem to be promising elsewhere.
People who play EDH enjoy these kinds of effects, and they’ll buy this card as soon as the price reduces to a more reasonable $20 per card. It’ll most likely go even lower, but who knows how well it’ll fare in all those commander ramp decks?
Crimson Vow is the most expensive card in Innistrad. Visit our MtG hub page for more Magic: The Gathering articles, card lists, and guides.
The date of publication is November 10th, 2021.
The “innistrad: midnight hunt” is a card that was released in the Innistrad set. It is an uncommon and can be found for around $1.
Related Tags
- innistrad: crimson vow card list
- innistrad: crimson vow spoilers
- innistrad: crimson vow release date
- innistrad
